To the editors of the New York Times
from Marshall Weber

Dear Editors,
While some type of memorial for those who perished in the horrific attack on the World Trade Center should be considered in the future, to aggressively erect (I use the world literally and purposefully here) a light polluting "Batcall" seems hasty and ill conceived.

As the civilian casualties in our war in Afghanistan mount and surpass those murdered in the WTC Towers it seems a little callous of us to go beyond the necessary memorial services with a flippant spectacle such as the Towers of Light.

Of course, the fact that the Towers of Light are directly plagiarized from the Cathedral of Light spectacle that Nazi architect Albert Speer designed for Hitler's triumphal Nuremburg Rally in 1934 should not surprise us. We are an amnesiac nation and the creators of the New York version are, like Speers, young, enthusiastic architects who seem completely oblivious to the cynical use of their luminous war-swords. Monumental hubris, after all, is typical of the occupations of both architects and professional rich kids like George and Osama.

Speers' version had two rows of sky lights instead of just two towers, but the similarity is startling right down to the duality of design, and the technology utilized. Then as today, columns of light are penetrating the skies, announcing a purifying crusade to both the gods and the world.

Substitute Bush for Hitler, substitute Moslems for Jews, substitute detainment camp (or occupied territories) for concentration camp, remind yourself that the actual word that our illegally unelected president used in his first public speech after 9/11 was "crusade," then check your history books and recall that Bush's grandfather Prescott (an infamous anti-Semite) made quite a bit of the family money by bonding the shipping lines that supplied early Nazi Germany with the steel it needed to pursue World War Two (with his Nazi sympathizer buddy Averill Harriman and the Morgan bank ) and you've got the ingredients for World War Three.

Proud to be a New Yorker!

Marshall Weber

Marshall Weber is an artist and teacher currently living in New York City. He holds both a BFA and an MFA (in Performance/Video) from the San Francisco Art Institute. Weber was co-founder of Artists Television Access in San Francisco and recently co-founded Booklyn Artists Alliance in New York City. Weber has spent the last decade working on a body of public artworks that evoke the tensions between theological and political identities. The Booklyn Artists Alliance is a national artist run non-profit organization that publishes, distributes and curates exhibitions of artists' books and related installation and performance art work. www.booklyn.org